Skip to content


Activism, Heroism and a Puppy named Bolt - What India needs today

Dear friends,

Yesterday, I saw a movie about a puppy named Bolt, who is conned into believing that he has super-powers that he uses for protecting the little girl who owns him. Midway through the movie, he realizes that he has no super-powers; he is just an ordinary, helpless puppy. He feels crushed by this realization. 

So Bolt faces a choice: to quit? Or to believe that he is still a hero, and keep struggling against the forces of evil?

The thought that his little girl still needs a hero helps him make the right decision: keep fighting.

I think we activists face the same choice. India needs a hero; are you willing to try? Am I willing to try?

Yes, we are not cut out to be heroes. Yes, as individuals, we are full of weaknesses and limitations. But India needs heroes now. She cannot wait another 10 years for someone better to emerge. You and I are the only ones currently available. So we will have to say, “My motherland needs a hero. Yes, I shall be that hero, although I am weak, fallible and maybe even helpless.”

We are trying to improve governance with RTI applications, PILs, advocacy, letter-baazi and other methods. Sometimes we feel that our actions are powerful. We feel confident and courageous.

And at other times, we are crushed by the realization that our methods are inadequate, our actions are weak, and we are helpless in the face of a gigantic corrupt system. And then we say to ourselves, “Oh, forget it! Activism doesn’t work. So let’s just return to living our ordinary lives, and forget about the nation.”

I have had such moments lately. Overwhelmed by my own limitations — the many promises that I make to myself and others, but fail to keep – I sometimes think such thoughts. I think about withdrawing into my own private space again and gradually disappearing from the activist space.

My re-energizing moment - Picking up shit from the road

I want to share with you what happened on Friday morning, about 8.20 am. I was on my way to giving my weekly classes on ‘Creative English & Editing’ for Second Year law students at Vile Parle. In my bag were 4-5 old newspapers — discussion material. After getting off the suburban train and climbing the skywalk, I had a prayerful thought: “God, take my hand, take my mind, make me serve. Tell me clearly what you want. I’ll do it, I promise.”

Minutes later, at the other end of the skywalk near SV Road, I saw a large lump of shit. I saw it and passed by. And then I passed by a fallen piece of paper. I then knew what I must do. I picked up the paper, went back to where the shit was, picked it up neatly and put it into a large empty flower pot by the side – out of everybody’s path. 

I felt happy. I had prevented the shit from spoiling someone’s day. If the shit had lay there long enough, a few people in the crowd would surely have stepped into it, and then walked, leaving a disgusting trail, for at least half an hour. Maybe they would have gotten into a rickshaw or train and ruined other people’s morning. Maybe they would have walked into their offices, and struggled in the washroom for half an hour to get the disgusting stuff out of the treads of his shoes. Or – if it was a businessman with an appointment – he might have cancelled it and just gone home to deal with the mess.

I felt energized. I had made my country and my city a bit better. And it was easy. I could do it, alone, quietly.

I thought about the previous day — Republic Day – when I had not done one single patriotic thing. Not one. I had not saluted a flag, not bought a flag from a street kid, not even watched the parade on TV, and not heard any patriotic songs by Lata Mangeshkar and Mohammed Rafi. I hadn’t even thanked anybody who sent me Republic Day SMSes. But today, I had justified my existence to my country and my beloved Mumbai.

Shit versus Personal Honour

However, as I turned the corner and neared the college gate, happy and self-satisfied, there it was again. More shit, a few metres from the college gates. Three or four large lumps of what looked like dog poop, right where people would walk.

Now I was in a quandary. Should I or shouldn’t do a repeat performance? I could easily ignore it and walk around it; after all, that’s what everybody else was doing. And why was it my problem? It was not. It was the job of the municipal cleaners, who may have come in half an hour. Or maybe they had come and gone, and this was fresh poop.

Some of the students walking in might be in my class. What would they think or feel, if they saw me bending and picking up poop with newspapers? Would they still respect me? I wondered.
I could not just walk away from it. I had no excuse; I was carrying a bagful of old newspapers that I could tear up and use.

And so, for the second time that morning, I picked up poop from the road. This time, I threw it into a corner where nobody would walk. 

My conscience as well as my hands were completely clean when I went up to class. We read 3-4 news items from the papers, and wrote about them. And then, near the end of our two-hour class, I told my students about my activities that morning. Going into flashback, I also mentioned how an activist friend – Vinita Singh — had scolded me over the phone, making me pick up my own dog’s shit from the road many, many months ago.

The collegians found the whole thing yucky, inspiring and hilarious… and yucky! 

After we all had a good laugh together, and all the jokes had subsided, I asked them to write about it in any way that they wanted to. I explicitly gave them permission to make it a joke at my expense, or a fictionalized story or a factual account – anything they felt like doing. 

Here are the pages from their notebooks:  http://tinyurl.com/Students-on-shit-picking 
I think they were definitely more witty and creative than usual. The headings are priceless!

Expressing our freedom with small acts of service

It’s not only about shit on the road. It’s about a lot of other things as well. There’s a simple way to improve our country, and it does not involve any special knowledge or skills. It’s by being alert and answering the call to action every time we hear it or see it.

Every now and then, driving along the highway, I see a rock left by a trucker who drove away after using it while repairing a punctured tyre. Or I see a divider block that has fallen onto the road. 

Seeing this, I curse the carelessness of others, and drive on. And then I wage an inner battle. Sometimes – and not always — after driving a kilometer, I tell myself that I too am equally careless. Because of my carelessness in letting that stone just lie there, a motorcyclist may have a bad accident while trying to avoid it in the darkness. I visualize his mother, his wife and his children after the accident. And knowing that I cannot face his family members if I have to, I take a U-turn and return to the spot. I roll up my sleeves and do the job that I wish others would do. I take the stone out of the way of motorists.

Sometimes I see drunkards lying with their arms and legs on the road, in the path of traffic. And I realize that it could easily be… God forbid, my father, my son or myself. (No, we don’t have drinks in our family, but that’s only by the grace of God.) And so I lift that person out of harm’s way, and make him lie down in a safer place. Yes, it’s a dirty job because drunkards lie in their puke and piss. But having dirty hands won’t kill me, but a dirty conscience might; I don’t know how to live with the thought that the person I ignored had his foot crushed under a car.

So what am I saying here?

What I’m trying to say here is: Let’s not get too caught up with the methods of activism. It may be RTI, PILs, letter-baazi and petitioning, agitating on the road, organizing dharnas and morchas, fasting, public meetings or whatever. It may be all of those… 

Or it may be none of those. I think our power to change the fortunes of India comes from our ability to do a job – not because it will bring us honour and fame, but because it needs doing. Life gives each one of us opportunities to be heroes many times over in our lifetime. It gifts us the opportunity to save many lives by just moving a rock out of the way. 

Yes, we will ourselves never know how many lives we saved, and how many tears we wiped by preventing the bad news from happening… and maybe that’s for the best.

“Ask not for whom the bell tolls,
It tolls for thee.
Now this bell tolling softly for another,
says to me, Thou must die…

No man is an island, entire of itself; 
Every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main. 
If a clod be washed away by the sea, Europe is the less…
Any man’s death diminishes me 
Because I am involved in mankind; 
and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls;
it tolls for thee. . . .

- from Meditation 17 by John Donne

There is anonymity and humility in such activism. There’s no reward for our ego, no Padma awards and recognitions, no newspaper reports. Just quiet self-satisfaction for the soul, and the knowledge that when I was called to serve, I served. Isn’t that wonderful?

Warm Regards,
Krish
98215 88114
thebravepedestrian@gmail.com

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, Personal, Philosophy, Poetry, Prayers.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Citizens’ candidates, beware of these pitfalls

20 Jan 2012: Citizens’ candidates and Independents foraying into electoral politics for the first time should watch out. The State Election Commission’s key circulars — available in Marathi only – have hidden traps for first-timers. As the dates for filing nomination papers for the BMC elections are only four days away, candidates should read these guidelines very carefully!

Things to watch out for:

1. Page 2 of the CIRCULAR DATED 30 JULY 2011 (http://tinyurl.com/MCGM-Election-Circ-1) mandates that every candidate shall open an independent bank account, and all election-related expenses must be incurred from this account only. The complete details of this account must be given to officials monitoring the elections. Many candidates – and especially women – may be taken by surprise when they are filing their nomination forms, or maybe even during scrutiny of nominations. That is when they may suddenly realize the need for a fresh and exclusive bank account, and then rush around trying to complete the bank’s formalities. If this happens at the eleventh hour, God help them!

2. Point 8 of the 24-PAGE CIRCULAR DATED 29 DEC 2011 (http://tinyurl.com/BMC-Elections-Dos-Donts) states, “After filing nominations, all expenses until the date of counting of votes must be as per the limits stipulated by Election Commission (i.e. Rs 5 lakhs). Details of expenses must be given to the election authorities before 2 pm daily. Also, after the elections, the total expenses during the election period (i.e. filing of nominations till counting date) must be given.” Is every independent candidate aware of this daily accounting duty?

3. Point 15 of this circular says that publicity material on electronic media needs to be given prior clearance by MCGM or the District Collector. Will TV journalists seek clearance for news about candidates? No. So this point adversely affects those who advertise on electronic media, and favours those who use the paid-news route to prachaar. This is an area for activists and journalists to debate and hopefully do something about.

4. Point 19 has a positive list and a negative list for videography – i.e. what is allowed and what is not allowed. The positive list encourages candidates to capture various wrongdoings (i.e. breach of election code of conduct and budget limits) by rivals, and to use the footage to blow the whistle! This method may be used to get winners dethroned after the elections. It may also be used by journalists. Candidates beware!

5. Scrutiny of nomination papers (which will happen on 1 Feb) is full of pitfalls. We are advised to have 2-3 alternative sets of nomination papers ready, with different sets of people as proposers and seconders from your electoral ward / constituency. Also, prepare your assets declaration affidavit after consulting your accountant and maybe also lawyer. Otherwise, there may be occasions for eleventh-hour panic! 

If in doubt on any point, call up your Code-of-Conduct officers from this list: http://tinyurl.com/Code-Conduct-Officers-BMC 

More useful links & circulars: 
Available election symbols (last page): http://tinyurl.com/Available-Symbols 

Hopefully, studying this will help independents / citizens’ candidates avoid last-minute blunders, and to give better competition to political parties and other seasoned khilaadis.

All the Best!
Krish
98215 88114

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Justice PB Sawant & Kolse Patil support Tareek Pe Tareek movement – Report of Yesterday’s Meeting

Dear Activist Friends,

Yesterday, five of us – G R Vora, Sunil Ahya, Meenal Rege, Mohammed Afzal and I – went and met Justice (Retired) PB Sawant at his residence in Pune. We were joined by Justice (Retd) BG Kolse Patil, with whom I had discussed our agenda earlier on phone. We had this meeting to discuss how to build a citizen’s movement for better judicial accountability, and the role that Justice Sawant & Kolse Patil could play in inspiring and spearheading such a movement to reform the judiciary. 

Currently, the Judicial Reforms discussion is confined to the conference halls and judicial reforms thinktanks run by experts such as Prashant Bhushan. For the purpose of bringing this movement out into the public domain, we discussed naming our campaign ‘Tareekh Pe Tareekh’, as it is something that common man easily relates with the judiciary.

Here is a group photo we took after the meeting: http://tinyurl.com/Justice-Sawant-KolsePatil-Pune 
(L to R: G R Vora, Mohd Afzal, Krish, Meenal Rege, Justice P B Sawant, Sunil Ahya and B G Kolse Patil.)

POINTS THAT WE DISCUSSED: 

If there is no timely justice, there is no rule of law, which means that there is no democracy.

Clean administration in the judiciary is an urgent need. Currently, this is a neglected area as chief justices of high courts have their eyes on advancing their careers. Improving court administration does not win them brownie points for being elevated to the Supreme Court.

Don’t slavishly address judges & magistrates as Your Lordship, Your Worship etc. (Say Sir instead.) Advocates’ associations must pass the necessary resolutions to stop the colonial practice of fawning before judges.

Cleanly criticizing what judges do in administrative capacity is not Contempt of Court. Pointing out the judge’s administrative lapses is within every citizen’s rights – but do so with all propriety.

Each judge has the necessary authority to streamline the procedural aspects and functioning of his own court, and to device methods of clearing backlogs etc. Each judge is responsible for administering his own court efficiently. Tell him so! Remind him, gently but persistently.

After a judgment is delivered, anybody may analyze and criticize it, as long as he does not impute motives to the judge or indulge in name-calling. Clean criticism is also not Contempt of Court. Judgments may be criticized on the basis of factual errors, and errors of legal reasoning.

We fearlessly criticize the prime minister and the government to death, but we can’t give a word of feedback to Judiciary, arguably India’s main bottleneck! For judicial reform to happen, this needs to change.

The citizens’ blind and unreasoned fear of judiciary’s Contempt powers is paralyzing the Judicial Reforms agenda. People are just not speaking up. This needs to change. Activists and the public must speak out for Courts to become more accessible and responsive to people’s needs. 

Activists must educate common people to lose their fear of Contempt of Court and speak out in a clear voice for judicial reforms.

Is there any real difference between judiciary in colonial era and now? Our courts & law equate activism and people’s agitation with criminal actions, sedition etc. – which is what the British used to do. This must change.

It is not Contempt to point out to judges that there is corruption among the court staff, and in specific departments such as the court registry and the department that prepares cause-lists. It is dereliction of duty on the part of judges to let corruption flourish under their very noses, while turning a blind eye.

Chief Justice of India alone cannot reform the judiciary. All the judges of the Supreme Court together can take the lead, but they must have support from High Courts and also the lawyers.  Much can be set right by modifying the procedures and rules, without any enactments and amendments in law. For instance, adjournments should not be given for the asking, as it is currently.

The government will need to be on board for those some key reforms that require enactment or amendments.

In India, over 60 % of those who have valid cause for going to court are placed outside the sphere of the justice system by: (a) poverty (b) ignorance & backwardness (c) great physical distance from courts. For such reasons, courts are not available to nomadic tribes, adivasis, backward classes etc. and others who reside in the villages, and whose nearest court is at the Tehsil / Taluka.

Supreme Court, High Court, Sessions, Magistrates Courts & City Civil Court – the main judiciary – currently have pendencies of over 3 crore cases. This is a desperate situation.

Most pendencies and delays are on account of litigation by the rich in High Courts and Supreme Court, engaging powerful lawyers for a high stakes game. This involves a powerful machinery and frequent contact with court staff and judges, great complications due to maneuvering and machinations, and a lot of getting around laws and rules. Such cases are very time consuming, and get in the way of speedy disposal of pendencies.

A lot of delays are created by senior counsels who have too much work, and therefore seek adjournments for their own convenience. As long as clients continue to run after senior counsels, this will continue to happen.

Most of the common man’s cases, involving inheritance, rent act, contract act, property etc. are being with by special courts and tribunals such as consumer court, cooperative court, family court, quasi-judicial bodies etc. Pendencies are relatively low in these courts.

To clear backlogs, we need more judges. Compared to India, USA has 8 times more judges and 4 times less population. Although shortage of judges is a huge problem in India, the judiciary is not pressing for new judges. There is no dearth of trained lawyers.

It is necessary to run courts in three shifts – morning, day and evening sessions. Judges  – especially those who have retired at early ages like 60 – can preside over morning and evening sessions.

What we discussed revolved around these letters that we recently sent to Chief Justice of India supported by 121 signatories from all over India.
To enable non-English speakers to understand and discuss the issues involved, the letter & covernote was translated in Hindi and Marathi by activists Sumer Bais and Meenal Rege respectively.



Addressed to Chief Justice of India S H Kapadia with whom the buck stops, this letter was also copied to:
1.       Chief Justices of 17 High Courts of India
2.       Presidents of 17 Bar Associations of India
3.       Union Minister for Law & Justice Salman Khurshid
4.       Secretary of Law & Justice Dept., Govt. of India
5.       Chairman and Secretary of the 19th Law Commission, New Delhi. 

In the near future, we will organize meetings in Mumbai for freeing the common man and the activist community of their phobias concerning the judiciary. JUSTICE P B SAWANT AND JUSTICE B G KOLSE PATIL HAVE AGREED TO ADDRESS SUCH MEETINGS and frankly address the fears that citizens have about Contempt of Court. They will also help us understand more about the administrative lapses of judges – for which we, the people of India, must fearlessly pull them up. 

Warm Regards
Krish
98215 88114
thebravepedestrian@gmail.com

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , .

No comments



CIC Shailesh Gandhi: “No Public Interest” in IDBI’s Rs 4200 cr Loan to Mumbai Airport

Central Information Commissioner Shailesh Gandhi is the poster boy of RTI activists. But an order given by him on 30th December 2011 will surely cause RTI activists to worry about his application of mind to the essential points.

Because, Mr Gandhi has told the average citizen of India that information about an infrastructure loan of Rs 4,200 crore given by a consortium of public sector banks headed by IDBI Bank Ltd. to Mumbai International Airport Ltd. (MIAL) is protected by their “fiduciary relationship” and therefore, it is none of the citizen’s business! 

The appellant in this case, Pune-based RTI activist Sanjay Shirodkar is of course amazed to hear this from Mr Gandhi. This order is likely to give a lot RTI activists all over the country a serious case of heartburn. 


LOOK AT THE FACTS OF THE CASE:

Mumbai International Airport is a Public Private Partnership (PPP) project.

MIAL is the PPP consortium in which Airport Authority of India (i.e. Govt of India) has a 26% shareholding. GVK Industries Ltd, and two rather dubious Mauritius-based khokha companies hold the remaining 74% shares.

MIAL is a major beneficiary of public funds – 2000 acres of prime land in Mumbai, valued at Rs 50,000 crore, for which it is paying AAI the princely sum of Rs 100 per annum as lease rent.

MIAL is playing a governmental role. It is in whole-and-sole control of Mumbai Airport. 
[All of this is the official position, confirmed by two previous orders given by Central Information Commission. CIC MM Ansari’s order in 2008, and then again by CIC Sushma Singh’s order in 2011: http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_MA_C_2008_00195_SS_M_57922.pdf ]

And now, on the other side of the transaction, you have IDBI Bank – India’s fourth-largest PUBLIC SECTOR BANK, which extends a huge loan consisting of Rs 4,200 CRORE OF PUBLIC MONEY. 

OUR QUESTIONS TO SHAILESH GANDHI:

1. CIC Shailesh Gandhi, Sir, a public sector bank extends a huge INFRASTRUCTURE LOAN (and not a personal loan for, say, GVK Reddy’s daughter’s wedding) to a dodgy consortium. And you say it is NOT public interest? You say that this information is exempted from information, given the “fiduciary relationship” between the lender and the borrower?

2. This loan is for a Public-Private Partnership project, presumably for the use of the good of the Indian citizen. And you say that it is none of our business? That the underlying documents and details of the transaction, which Sanjay Shirodkar asked for, is a private matter between the two transacting parties?

3. MIAL is a well-known fugitive or defaulter as far as the Sunshine Law is concerned. They are consistently stonewalling activists from every angle. No sooner CIC orders them to disclose information, than MIAL goes to Delhi High Court and gets a stay. The only way to get any information from them is to go to other entities like IDBI. Surely you, of all the people, know that?

4. Public Private Partnership (PPP) projects of various kinds are, as a group, fugitives from RTI Act. They are regularly stonewalling and defying orders of Information Commissions. Under the cover of this secrecy, they are looting public moneys from various government entities. Hence the urgent need for citizens to get information from other routes such as public sector banks lending to them. Surely, Sir, you are aware of this?

5. And last but not least, on a very personal note: Three years ago, you introduced the appellant Sanjay Shirodkar to me, specifically to assist him in getting information from MIAL. Sir, have you forgotten?

Under the circumstances, we citizens have no option but to take the position that if seeking Public Private Partnerships’ information is not in public interest, then maybe the PPP projects themselves are not in public interest. Evidently, they are only in the private interest of the private parties involved, and the ministers and officials who are in their pay.

Maybe it is time for us to agitate for immediate closure of all PPP projects.
[If anybody should wish to contact RTI appellant Sanjay Shirodkar, his contact details are sanjay.shirodkar@gmail.com  097663 13997 ]

Warm Regards,
Krish
98215 88114 

PS: Read the related back-story: Govt of India leased 2000 acres to GVK Ltd for Rs 100 p.a. Is this justified? http://tinyurl.com/MIAL-2000-acres-khokha-cos 

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



‘No More Tareek Pe Tareekh’ letter posted today to CJI & 17 High Courts, with 121 signatures

Dear Friends,

Today, activist G R Vora dispatched letters to 41 most empowered persons in the Indian judiciary, law ministry and law commission. We hope that they will read, understand and act upon these suggestions. 

This letter-writing exercise was our way of wishing for a brighter 2012 for all our fellow-citizens. We firmly believe that our governance systems, including the judiciary, must improve and will improve. We believe that together, we can make a difference – especially for the common man whom Gandhiji called Daridra-Narayan.

Supported by 121 signatories from across India (a majority from Mumbai), this letter was drafted with many key inputs from Adv. Rasheed Qureshi of Supreme Court and Adv. Ameet Mehta of Bombay High Court. 

Addressed to Chief Justice of India S H Kapadia with whom the buck stops, this letter was also copied to: 
1. Chief Justices of 17 High Courts of India
2. Presidents of 17 Bar Associations of India
3. Union Minister for Law & Justice Salman Khurshid
4. Secretary of Law & Justice Dept., Govt. of India
5. Chairman and Secretary of the 19th Law Commission, New Delhi.


To enable non-English speakers to understand and discuss the issues involved in making judicial remedies available to the common man, the letter etc. was translated in Hindi and Marathi by activists Sumer Bais and Meenal Rege.

Here are the 36 Courier Receipts: http://tinyurl.com/Letters2CJIs-Courier-Receipts 
(As courier service was not available to Sikkim, it was sent by post. Receipts of letters sent to four Presidents of Bar Associations are also not included here.)

The cost of this entire project – about Rs 2000 — was borne by G R Vora. Of course, some of us will chip in with our contributions.

Thank you all for participating in this act of faith. God bless you all, God bless our beloved country. And wish you a marvelous New Year in service of the country. May 2012 be the year of change that we have been praying for, and working for.

Warmly,
Krish
98215 88114

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, Philosophy, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



समस्या है खुद न्यायपालिका — CJI को पत्र

भारत के मुख्य न्यायाधीश, उच्च न्यायालय और अन्य लोगों को भेजने के लिए इस पत्र पर हस्ताक्षर करें


प्रिय मित्रों, 


निन्यानवे प्रतिशत से अधिक भारतीयों के लिए, न्यायिक उपचार की मांग असंभव है. अदालत में जाना बाधाओं से भरा हुआ है , जैसे –

  

  • बहुत महंगे वकील 

  • “तारीख पे तारीख”  – लगातार तहकूबी की वजह से विलंब 

  • मामूली कारणों पर स्थगन आदेश  (स्टे ऑर्डर)

  • कठिन और समय लेने वाली  अदालती प्रक्रियायें

  • ब्रिटिश युग से चली आ रही गुलामी परक शब्दों से भरी अदालती भाषा 

  • बार बार होने वाले न्यायालयीन अवकाश (कोर्ट वेकेशंस) से न्याय का प्रवाह टूटता है जो फैसलों में देरी के लिए जिम्मेदार है


हम सभी देखते हैं कि न्यायपालिका कई प्रशासनिक और अर्ध-न्यायिक प्रक्रियाओं (क्वॉसी जुडीशियल प्रोसीडिंग्स) के आदेश को बेमानी बना देती है. उदाहरण के लिए, हमारे नागरिक निकाय, अवैध संरचनाओं को  ध्वस्त करने और कब्जा करने वालों को  बेदख़ल करने में असहाय हैं क्योंकि अदालतें,  नियमित रूप से  दीर्घकालिक परिणामों के बारे में सोचे बिना विध्वंस और बेदखली नोटिस पर स्थगन आदेश देती रही है. हर महीने यह देखा गया है कि इन स्थगन आदेशों की वजह से, सूचना आयुक्तों के  कई अच्छे आदेश निश्प्रभावी हुए है.


लेकिन न्यायाधीशों  के सामने कोई भी प्रतिक्रिया रखने की हमारी हिम्मत नहीं होती, क्योंकि हम अदालत की अवमानना के लिए जेल में जाने से डरते हैं. हम जजों के निर्विवाद अधिकार और उनकी शक्ति से भयभीत होते हैं क्योंकि  वे परोक्ष या अपरोक्ष रुप से हमें बहुत नुकसान पहुँचा सकते हैं.


विडंबना देखें,  हम प्रधानमंत्री और राष्ट्रपति की कडे शब्दों में आलोचना करने से नहीं डरते लेकिन न्यायाधीशों को निर्विवाद सच बात बताने की सोच से भी कांप उठते है. 


मित्रों, चलिये, अब हम यह डरना बंद करें. हमें न्यायपालिका से जुड़े इस कड़वे सच को स्पष्ट रूप से व्यक्त करना होगा. हम न्यायपालिका से  स्वयं सुधार के लिये कहें. कृपया याद रखें, अदालतें केवल आम आदमी की सेवा के लिए मौजूद है, इसके अलावा उनके अस्तित्व का और कोई अन्य कारण नहीं. आम आदमी की सेवा करने में वे लगातार विफल रहे हैं, इसलिए यह हमारा कर्तव्य है कि हम इस असफलता को उल्लेखित करें और तत्काल परिवर्तन की मांग करें.


हम आठ लोगों ने (जिनमें से पांच सुप्रीम कोर्ट, दिल्ली और बंबई उच्च न्यायालयों में  कार्यरत  अधिवक्ता हैं) सच बात कहने का निर्णय लिया है. 


25 दिसंबर 2011 को हम, भारत के मुख्य न्यायाधीश, सभी उच्च न्यायालयों के मुख्य न्यायाधीश और बार एसोसिएशन (वकील संघटना) के अध्यक्ष, केंद्रीय कानून मंत्री और भारतीय विधि आयोग को इस पत्र की प्रतियां भेजेंगे.


सुप्रीम कोर्ट के वकील श्री अब्दुल रशीद कुरैशी और बॉम्बे हाई कोर्ट के वकील श्री अमित मेहता से प्राप्त महत्वपूर्ण जानकारियों के आधार पर कई संशोधनों के बाद हमने नीचे दिये पत्र का मसौदा बनाया है.


हम चाहते हैं आप सभी इस पत्र पर हस्ताक्षर करके हमारे साथ शामील हों.  हस्ताक्षरित पत्र में शामिल होने के लिये कृपया अपना ईमेल पता, व्यवसाय, शहर और संपर्क नंबर इस ईमेल पर भेजें: grvora1@gmail.com


धन्यवाद. 

कृष्णराज राव  thebravepedestrian@gmail.com

98215 88114 

(हिंदी अनुवादक सुमेर बैस)


अनुवादित पत्र का मसौदा


25 दिसम्बर 2011 


प्रति, 

माननीय  न्यायमूर्ति श्री एस एच कपाड़िया 

भारत के मुख्य न्यायाधीश 

द्वारा/ रजिस्ट्रार 

भारतीय सर्वोच्च न्यायालय,

तिलक मार्ग, नई दिल्ली - 110 001 

 

प्रतिलिपि: 

सभी उच्च न्यायालयों के माननीय मुख्य न्यायाधीश

द्वारा/   रजिस्ट्रार जनरल 

 

अध्यक्ष, बार एसोसिएशन (वकील संघटना)

 

श्री सलमान खुर्शीद 

केंद्रीय विधि और न्याय मंत्री 

साउथ ब्लॉक, नई दिल्ली 

 

माननीय न्यायमूर्ति श्री पीवी रेड्डी 

अध्यक्ष, 19  वाँ  विधि आयोग 

दुसरी  मंजिल, विधि संस्थान भवन 

सुप्रीम कोर्ट के सामने

नई दिल्ली 110 001. 


आपने न्यायपालिका को आम आदमी की पहुंच से परे रखा है, 

विशेष रूप से वरिष्ठ नागरिक. 

कृपया इस स्थिति में सुधार करें 

 

प्रिय महोदय, 


हम भारत के लोग आपको अपने न्यायिक क्षमता में नहीं बल्कि भारत की न्यायपालिका के प्रशासनिक प्रमुख के रूप में संबोधित कर रहे हैं. महोदय, इससे पहले कि आप कुछ महीनों में निवृत्त हो, हम आशा करते हैं कि आप एक प्रबुद्ध प्रशासनिक सुधारक के रूप में अपने ज्ञान का उपयोग समाज हित में करें, और हमारे राष्ट्र को नुकसान पहुँचा रही कुछ पुरातन न्यायिक परंपराओं को खत्म करें. 


महोदय, उच्च न्यायपालिका के निरंकुश तरीकों से पीडित प्रतिवादी और याचिकाकर्ता बोल नहीं सकते. उन्हें डर रहता है कि आपके भ्राता न्यायाधीश कुछ मनमाने ढंग से आदेश जारी करके उनके मामलों को  नुकसान पहुँचायेंगे. हम उनकी ओर से बोल रहे हैं. 


भारत की न्यायिक मशीनरी वरिष्ठ नागरिकों के लिए उपलब्ध नहीं रह गई है. कोई भी वरिष्ठ नागरिक मामला दर्ज नही कर सकता, क्योंकि 15-20 साल तक निर्णय पर पहुंचने की संभावना नहीं. तब तक वह या तो बूढ़ा हो गया होगा, या फिर उसका देहांत हो गया होगा. 


आम जनता और बहुत सारे धनी लोग भी  अदालत में नहीं  जा सकते क्योंकि यह लाखों रुपयों का ऐसा बेक़ाबू खर्च है, जो उनके जीवन भर की पूंजी को खत्म कर देता है. 


दशकों से, न्यायिक मशीनरी का प्रशासन सकल रुप से  विफल हुआ है. कई न्यायाधीशों ने विभिन्न मंचों पर अपने भाषणों में इसकी ओर इशारा किया है. ये भाषण सिर्फ सुनने में अच्छे लगते हैं,  बाद में इस बारे में कुछ भी नहीं  किया जाता. 


“ न्यायपालिका की स्वतंत्रता” के सिद्धांत ने न्यायपालिका में सुधार करने में सरकार और संसद को अक्षम कर रखा है. केवल न्यायपालिका ही स्वंय सुधार कर सकती है. सुप्रीम कोर्ट सम्पूर्ण अधीक्षण की समग्र अदालत है. न्यायपालिका की प्रशासनिक शक्तियाँ सिर्फ आप के हाथों में ही निहित हैं और आप इनका पुरजोर उपयोग करें. यदि आप ऐसा नहीं करते हैं तो कोई भी आपको यह करने के लिए मजबूर नही कर सकता. कोई भी अपनी आवाज नही उठा सकता, आपकी प्रशासनिक विफलता के लिये आलोचना नहीं कर सकता और आपकी जगह एक सक्षम प्रशासक प्रतिस्थापित करने की धमकी नहीं दे सकता, क्योंकि ऐसा करना अवमानना को आमंत्रित करना होगा.


केवल आप, भारत के माननीय मुख्य न्यायाधीश, हमारी न्यायपालिका के सुधारों का आरंभ कर सकते हैं. पहला कदम होगा आप न्यायपालिका की खामियां खुलकर स्वीकार करें और इसे बदलने के लिए समय सारिणी के साथ एक रूपरेखा निर्धारित करें.


चाहे हम किसी भी अदालत के समक्ष वादी हों या न हों, न्यायपालिका की अनुपलब्धता और संरक्षण के अभाव की वजह से हम सभी हमारे दैनिक जीवन में गंभीर विकलांगता और कुंठाओं से ग्रासित हैं. कृपया हमारी  आवाज़ सुनें क्योंकि हम इन परिस्थितियों से  पीड़ित है.

  

कुछ समस्याएं और प्रस्तावित समाधान: 

  

समस्या 1: बहुत ही आसानी से अनिश्चित काल के लिए स्थगन आदेश मिलना. महोदय,  कई निचली अदालतें, अधिकरण, अर्ध-न्यायिक मंच (जैसे सूचना आयोग) के अच्छे तर्कपूर्ण निर्णयों को उच्च न्यायालयों से स्थगन आदेश (स्टे ऑर्डर) दिए गये हैं. विभिन्न प्रशासकीय आदेश और डिमॉलिशन नोटिस, जो कि महानगर पालिकाओं द्वारा ग़ैरक़ानूनी बांधकाम (कन्स्ट्रक्शन) के खिलाफ जारी किए जाते हैं उन्हें, अनिश्चित काल के लिए स्थगित कर दिया जाता है. स्थगन आदेश को हटाने के लिए बेहद मशक्कत करनी पड़ती है. ऐसा करना विभिन्न क़ानूनों के लिए, क़ानून प्रवर्तन एजेन्सियों के लिए और क़ानून का पालन करने वाले सामान्य नागरिकों के लिए एक बंद गली साबित होता है और उसके मन में वैधानिक तरीकों के बारे में उदासीनता पैदा करता है.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: सबसे पहले यह निर्देश जारी करें कि अगर किसी भी अदालत ने स्थगन आदेश जारी किया है तो वह मामला अपने आप “फास्ट ट्रेक” मामला हो जाए. अधिकतम एक सप्ताह के अंतराल की तिथियाँ दी जाए ताकि जिस पार्टी ने स्थगन आदेश लिया है वह न्यायिक देरी का अनुचित लाभ ना ले सके. इस मामले का निपटारा तीन महीने में हो जाना चाहिए और असाधारण मामलों में  छह महिने तक. दूसरे, यह अनिवार्य करें कि छह महिने के बाद यह स्थगन आदेश अपने आप समाप्त हो जाए ताकि उसका लाभार्थी  देरी करने की रणनीति में शरण न ले.


समस्या 2: बहुत ही आसानी से मामला तहकूब होना (ऐद्जोर्न्मेंट). उच्च न्यायालय और सभी निचली अदालतों की कार्यवाही एक हिन्दी फिल्म के प्रचलित वाक्यांश से अभिव्यक्त हो सकती है — “तारीख पे तारीख”. सत्र और मैजिस्ट्रेट अदालतों की कार्यवाहियों को तो समझा भी नहीं जा सकता. अंडरट्रायल्स और आरोपी पार्टियों को हर 2-3 महिनों में तलब किया जाता है और नई तारिखों के साथ वापस भेज दिया जाता है. उन्हें यह भी जानकारी नहीं होती कि उनकी सुनवाई क्यों नहीं हुई. उनकी प्रस्तुतियों को ध्यानपूर्वक नहीं सुना जाता. कभी कभार अगर ज़ोर लगाया जाए तो अदालत के कर्मचारी कमजोर स्पष्टीकरण देते हैं.  अदालत, पुलिस और आम जनता के हज़ारो कामकाजी घंटे बरबाद हो जाते हैं. और जैसे जैसे वर्ष बीतते जाते हैं, स्मृतियाँ धूमील होती जाती हैं, गवाह पलट जाते हैं और न्याय अर्थहीन हो जाता है. इस देरी का लाभ सिर्फ़ वकिलों को ही होता है.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: कृपया निर्देश जारी करके यह अनिवार्य करें कि वकिलों और पार्टियों पर उत्तरोत्तर ऐद्जोर्न्मेंट के लिए बढ़ता हुआ जुर्माना लागू किया जाए, जैसे प्रथम ऐद्जोर्न्मेंट पर 2000 रुपयों का जुर्माना, दूसरे ऐद्जोर्न्मेंट पर 5000 रुपयों का जुर्माना और तीसरे और अंतिम ऐद्जोर्न्मेंट पर 15000 रुपयों का जुर्माना.


समस्या 3: तारिखों के बीच का व्यापक अंतराल. कभी कभी तिथियों के बीच का अंतराल छह महिने तक का होता है, मुक़दमे सालों और दशकों तक खींचते चले जाते हैं. इस वजह से कभी कभी  न्यायालयीन हिरासत में रखे गये आरोपी को जीवन और स्वतंत्रता के मौलिक अधिकारों से वंचीत होना पड़ता है.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: सबसे पहले निर्देश जारी करके अनिवार्य करें कि तिथियों  का अंतराल 15-30 दिनों के भीतर हो और कुल 10 तिथियों से ज़्यादा न हो. कई अधिवक्ताओं ने उनके अध्ययन से यह राय जाहिर की है कि ट्रायल कोर्टस्, उच्च न्यायालय और सर्वोच्च न्यायालयों में चल रहे मामले 7 से 10 तारिखों के बीच अपने अंतिम निर्णय पर पहुँच सकते हैं. दूसरे, यह अनिवार्य करें कि विरोधियों/ उत्तरदाताओं को अग्रीम सूचना (नोटीस) दी जाए ताकि पहली दो तारिखों की व्यर्थता समाप्त हो सके.


समस्या 4: आश्चर्यों की अदालते, क़ानून की नहीं . अपने बदव्यवहार के पीछे छिपकर, अपने अवमानना के अधिकार के कवच में न्यायाधीश बिल्कुल सनकी अंतरीम आदेश, राहतें और निर्णय देते हैं जो किसी भी क़ानूनी तर्कों पर खरे नहीं उतर सकते. निचली अदालतों के कई तर्कशुद्ध निर्णयों को खारीज़ किया जाता है या उच्चतर न्यायालय उन्हें  कमजोर आधारों पर फिर खोलती हैं. ऐसे निर्णय अक्सर प्रभावशाली या धनी व्यक्तियों के पक्ष में होते हैं.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: कृपया न्यायिक लेखा परीक्षण तंत्र की स्थापना करें जो संदिग्ध निर्णय और उनके तर्कों की जाँच करें. जिन न्यायाधीशों ने तर्कसंगत निर्णय नहीं लिए हैं उनकी पुछताछ हो और उनके ही साथियों द्वारा वे आलोचित हों.  


समस्या 5: वरिष्ठ वकीलों की भारी फीस और दलाली का नेटवर्क. वरिष्ठ वकील अंधाधुंद फीस चार्ज कर रहे हैं, जैसे प्रत्येक उपस्थिती के लिए 5 से 20 लाख रुपये. भले ही उन्हें एक स्थगन आदेश का अनुरोध करने के लिए कुछ  क्षण ही कोर्ट मे खड़ा होना हो, वे पूरी  फीस चार्ज करते हैं. कुछ मिनिटों के परामर्श के लिए भी वे लाखों  रुपये लेते हैं. अगर उन्हें अन्य कोर्ट में खड़ा होना हो तो प्रत्येक उपस्थिति के लिए यह आंकड़ा करोड़ों तक जाता है. कम जाने माने अधिवक्ता, दलाली  के बदले ऐसे बड़े अधिवक्ताओं की नियुक्ति के लिए अपने ग्राहकों  को मनाते हैं. ऐसे अमीर क़ानूनी दिग्गज वकिलों के क्लर्क और जूनियर्स अदालतों को “मैनेज” करते हैं ताकि आरामदायक तारिख़ें मिलें और बेंच की रीअसाइनमेंट हो जिसमें मित्रतापूर्ण न्यायाधीश हो. ऐसे  वकीलों का चेहरा और धनशक्ति यह सुनिश्चीत करता है कि भले ही मामले में कोई दम न हो, न्यायाधीश उनके व्याख्यान बड़े ध्यान से सुनते हैं. ऐसे वरिष्ठ वकीलों से प्रेरणा पाकर, कम जाने-माने वकिल भी अपनी फीस अंधाधुंध बढ़ा देते हैं. इस तरह से न्याय आम आदमी की पहुँच से दूर हो जाता है और अमीरों को अनुचित लाभ मिलता है. आजकल कंपनियाँ ही ऐसे वकीलों को वहन कर सकती हैं.  

प्रस्तावित समाधान: न्याय प्रक्रिया आम आदमी को उपलब्ध हो इसके लिए कृपया न्यायपालिका के सभी स्तरों पर सभी वकीलों के लिए एक उचित शुल्क संरचना लागू करें, विशेषकर उच्च न्यायपालिका में. जो अनिवार्य शुल्क संरचना का उल्लंघन करें, तो उनकी सनद रद्द कर दी जाए.


समस्या 6: अहंभाव और चापलूसी की संस्कृति. वकील लगातार ब्रिटिश काल की अभिव्यक्तियाँ, जैसे “युवर लॉर्डशिप”, “मिलार्ड”, “प्रेयर्स”, “वी क्रेव युवर लीव”, “वी हंम्बली प्रे”, “फॉर धीस फेवर वी विल एवर बी  इन युवर डेट” आदि, का प्रयोग करके न्यायाधिशों के अहंभाव को बढ़ाते हैं. अदालती लेखन सामग्री में भी ऐसी गुलामी परक भाषा पाई जाती है, जबकि नागरिक संविधान द्वारा उसे दिए गए अधिकारों के आधार पर ही न्याय माँग रहा है, किसी एहसान की भीख नहीं माँग रहा. न्यायाधीश उन वकिलों और नागरिकों को न्याय से वंचित करते हैं जो इस संस्कृति का विरोध करते हैं. जो नागरिक स्वयं “पार्टी इन परसन” के रूप में स्वयं का मामला लड़ने के लिए अदालत के सामने हाज़िर होते हैं, उन्हें परेशान किया जाता है. न्यायपालिका के परिसर में इस तरह गुलामी को बढ़ावा देना, समानता, जीवन और स्वतंत्रता के मौलिक अधिकारों का उल्लंघन है.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: कृपया ऐसी अनावश्यक भाषा पर प्रतिबंध लगाएं और सुनिश्चित करें कि अब भाषण और लेखन में सभी न्यायाधिशों के लिए केवल “महोदय” शब्द का ही प्रयोग हो.


समस्या 7: अदालतों में झूठे सबूत और झूठी गवाहियाँ देना नज़रअंदाज़ किया जाता है. हालाकि, अदालतों के औचित्य के उल्लंघन पर सज़ा देने में शीघ्रता दिखाई जाती है, न्यायाधीश तब नाराज़ नहीं होते जब उनके आदेशों का सरासर उल्लंघन किया जाता है. इसके अलावा वे झूठे  दस्तावेज, झूठी गवाहियाँ और एकमुश्त झूठ को नज़रअंदाज कर देते हैं. इससे अपराधिओं का पलड़ा भारी हो जाता है, और निरपराध नागरिकों के साथ अन्याय होता है. 

प्रस्तावित समाधान: कृपया हर अदालत में आदेशों के उल्लंघन और झूठी गवाहियों के मुद्दों के लिए एक समय निर्धारित करें.


समस्या 8: लंबी छुट्टियाँ और कम काम के घंटो की ब्रिटिश काल की प्रथा. निचली न्यायालय वर्ष में 240 दिन, और उच्च न्यायालयें 210 दिन काम करते हैं. सर्वोच्च न्यायालय सिर्फ 180 दिन, यानी कि आधे साल, काम करता है. गर्मियों में सम्पूर्ण न्यायपालिका (सभी न्यायाधीश, वकील, बाबू , आदि) लगातार छुट्टियों की वजह से 5 से 7 हफ्ते बंद रहती है. सर्वोच्च न्यायालय 10 मई से 30 जून तक छुट्टी पर चला जाता है. प्रशासन के अन्य किसी भी अंग के पास ऐसी उदार सुविधा नहीं है. कई अदालतों में तो प्रतिदिन 3 से 4 घंटे ही काम होता है. बढ़ते हुए लंबित मामलों के परिप्रेक्ष में इस तरह की कामकाजी आदतें सिर्फ़ अनुचित ही नहीं बल्कि दुर्लभ राष्ट्रीय संसाधन (न्यायालय के संसाधन) का दुरुपयोग भी है, और हमारी जनता की आपराधिक उपेक्षा भी है.

प्रस्तावित समाधान: सबसे पहले कृपया छुट्टियों की संख्या सीमित करके 60 दिन कर दें (यह भी अन्य क्षेत्रों से ज़्यादा ही होगा). दूसरे, सामुहिक छुट्टियों पर पाबंदी लगा दें. छुट्टियों को इस तरह से नियोजित किया जाए ताकि पूरा कोर्ट बंद न हो. अंत मे कृपया यह अनिवार्य करें कि हर न्यायाधीश  प्रतिदिन कमसे कम 6 घंटे मामलों की सुनवाई करे. 



महोदय, कई नागरिक मंचो ने बड़े धीरज से इन विचारों को संकलित किया है और कई वर्षों तक अपनी बात रखते रहे हैं, लेकिन न्यायपालिका ने उन्हें सदा अनदेखा किया. अब सभी का धीरज एक सीमा तक पहुँच गया है. हमें उम्मीद है कि आप निवृत्त होने से पहले अपने ऊँचे पद का उपयोग करेंगे और तत्काल इन अत्यावश्यक सुधारों को लागू करेंगे. हमें यह भी उम्मीद है कि आप स्पष्ट रूप से अपना अभिप्राय देश के सामने रखेंगे और सुविचारी नागरिकों को आपके हाथ मजबूत करने की सक्षमता प्रदान करेंगे.


भवदीय, 

  

1. ए. राशीद कुरैशी, 7838408078 rasheed1357@yahoo.co.in , अधिवक्ता, दिल्ली 

 

2. जी. आर. वोरा, 9869195785 grvora1@gmail.com , रोगविज्ञानी, मुंबई 

 

3. कृष्णराज राव, 9821588114 thebravepedestrian@gmail.com , पत्रकार, मुंबई 

 

4. ए. आयर्स रॉड्रिक्स, 9822684372 airesrodrigues1@gmail.com , अधिवक्ता, गोवा 

 

5. ए. अमित मेहता, 9821283232 ameetvmehta@gmail.com , अधिवक्ता, मुम्बई 

 

6. ए. आर्यन यादव, 9717468613 aryanscadvocate@gmail.com , अधिवक्ता, दिल्ली 

 

7. रमिज़ तौहिद, 09891664368 tauheedrameez@gmail.com , अभियंता, दिल्ली 

  

8. ए. विनोद संपत, 9324038095 vinodsampat@gmail.com , अधिवक्ता, मुम्बई


IMPORTANT NOTE: 

The original draft of this letter was in English. It was signed by 115 persons as of 22 December 9.30 p.m. See http://tinyurl.com/Chief-Justice-Letter-E3 

The above-named eight persons were the first signatories of this letter in English, before it was circulated in the public domain.

This letter has been translated into Hindi by Sumer Bais, an activist, and has been adequately proof-checked by Meenal Rege. 

The aim of this translation is to reach a wider audience and raise awareness of this important issue, and to gather wider support.

The above mentioned eight original signatories, or any of the later signatories, are not to be held responsible for inaccuracies in translation. Their signature is to the original English letter only.

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Nahar Amrit Shakti Township in Powai — a Scam with thousands of Victims

Welcome to the Hotel California
Such a lovely place (Such a lovely place), such a lovely face
Plenty of room at the Hotel California, any time of year (Any time of year)
You can find it here…

“Last thing I remember, I was running for the door
I had to find the passage back to the place I was before
“Relax,” said the night man, “We are programmed to receive.
You can check-out any time you like, but you can never leave!”

Have you heard this Eagles classic song titled Hotel California? It sums up the experience at Nahar’s Amrit Shakti Chandivali (Powai) township. You can buy a flat from builder S B Nahar… But if you want to sell it and leave, he will use unlawful and fraudulent means to prevent you. 

The builder wants total control over the market for sale of the flats, and therefore is using every trick in the book to prevent second sales. He is effectively killing the secondary market, and preventing investors and residents from selling their flats. He is doing this to artificially restrict the availability of flats, so that he can continue to hike up the prices of the flats he sells by a few lakhs every couple of weeks. Nahar’s rates are astronomical, but in the absence of second-sales, buyers don’t have a choice. But some time after buying a flat at Amrit Shakti Powai, the residents start feeling financially crippled, as all kinds of unfavourable terms and conditions are thrust upon them… and they find themselves powerless to resist.  

In order to prevent estate agents from spoiling his artificially created market, Nahar either threatens them to stay away, or hires them as his own booking agents.  

Details of How the Nahar Amrit Shakti fraud is carried out:

Nestled on a hill near Powai Lake, a stone’s throw from the posh Hiranandani complex neighbourhood, Nahar’s Amrit Shakti sounds like a heavenly place to people living outside. To those living afar, booking a new flat at Nahar’s Amrit Shakti seems like a brilliant decision to make all your dreams come true… but once you are there, you slowly come to realize that it is a living hell. See this misleading sales brochure of Nahar properties: http://tinyurl.com/Nahar-Amrit-Shakti-HDFC-scam 
See this fraudulent promotional video of this Chandivali township: http://powai.info/2011/12/14/nahars-amrit-shakti-8-new-towers-promotional-video/

 
The promotional brochures and videos, and the sales-booking office staff mislead you to believe that this massive township project, consisting of about 5000 flats and a dozen towers, is heaven on earth, and a premium investment destination for desi people abroad. The HDFC (Housing Development Finance Corporation) brand in this brochure has been inserted as a badge of honour to assure you that all things will be done according to law to safeguard your rights as an owner. HDFC adds credibility to this dreamy, fluffy brochure… and that is where the dishonesty lies. It is a trap to ensnare starry-eyed buyers. Investors who believe in the HDFC brand are being fleeced of lakhs of rupees, and they are finding it impossible to resist as their consumer rights and fundamental rights are taken away from them.

In this gated community, round-the-corner from Powai police station, there is no law. S B Nahar (Nahar Builders & Developers) is the law here. The security men speak softly, but don’t be fooled, they enforce the builder’s law here; if you don’t behave, they won’t let you in. In this Powai township, you are alone in your fight against the Nahar Builder, his army of uniformed maintenance men and security men, and his friends in the administration and government. If you have a dispute with this builder, you are powerless in the stranglehold of Nahar Builders & Developers!

THE LAWS OF NAHAR’S AMRIT SHAKTI PROPERTIES:

1. Pay-and-forget parking. Some people were promised exclusive closed parking, and some were promised open parking slots. For these promises, the residents paid amounts ranging from Rs 2 to 5 lakh per marked parking space (although it is illegal to charge for parking spaces, which are common amenities and therefore the property of the cooperative society). The helpless residents, who have paid these amounts 3-4 years ago, are still parking their posh cars haphazardly in the compounds, wherever the security men tell them to. The ground floor was originally designed for basement or stilt parkings, but these spaces are daily being enclosed with walls and sold as part of these duplexes before the very eyes of the residents. 

2. Non-existent amenities. Anybody who paid for a 1500 sq. ft house got only 750 sq. ft of carpet area (plus balconies shown in the plan as flower-beds). Inherent in the price of the flat is the price of club, pool and lavish amenities in their backyard, such as a playground and a modern school etc. All these luxurious amenities shown in the brochure or promised by the sales staff have been “under construction” for over five years now. Without much of these amenities ready, the builder fraudulently thrusts possession on to the owners at very short notice of a few weeks. In this situation, people are left with no time to think and react properly. They are forced to choose between two bad choices: (a) If they refuse to take possession without those amenities, Nahar terminates their agreement and forfeits their advance amount – usually 20% of the cost. (b) If they take possession without these amenities, they are bound by a clause in their agreement which specifies that they shall not complain about any lack of amenities, faulty construction etc. after taking possession.

3. Formation of cooperative society being actively obstructed. Although many of the buildings in this township are almost fully occupied (e.g. Tilia-Tulipia, Arum- Allamanda, Iris-Ivy, and Mirabilis-Mimosa), the builder is not fulfilling his legal obligation of calling an AGM, enabling a cooperative society to be formed and handing over charge of the building and amenities to the cooperative society. Is it just neglect? No, there is a method behind the madness of not forming cooperative societies, and Nahar is threatening the residents who wish to unite and form a cooperative society. People who live with their family and children are too afraid to oppose Nahar’s “omnipresence” in Chandivali. On 12th August 2011, some residents finally managed to unite and organize a morcha against the builder. Within minutes, the local sub-inspector materialized and threatened to impose a curfew on this peaceful gathering. Nahar openly threatened the residents, saying that if they insisted on forming a society, he would discontinue construction of the amenities that they had already paid for. 

4. Ongoing encroachment of common space and amenities. Collection of an average of Rs 5 lakhs from each of the 4,000 residents here, has given S B Nahar about Rs 200 crore of interest-free play money. Nahar is using some of this play money to build unlawful “duplex” dwelling units on the podium-floors of each building, which are part of the common amenities where the society office and play area were earlier shown. Each of these massive duplexes is an encroachment by the builder, and these are being sold with a further 2000 square foot fenced backyard – land that is part of the the buildings’ amenities. These grand flats measuring about 4,000 sq. ft. carpet will fetch the builder nothing short of Rs 5 cr. each. A narrow stairway in each of these duplex flats leads to a room on the ground floor, which was sold as common parking.  This encroachment would not be possible if a cooperative society and managing committee were formed, and took charge of society premises. 

5. Putting up an illegal 22-storey building on a reservation plot. S B Nahar had promised the residents of Magnolia Enclave & Orchid Enclave  – large societies with many buildings – a very big garden and parking area in a reservation plot. But instead of building these common amenities, he built a 22-storeyed building named Bluebell on that plot, and started selling the flats before the eyes of the residents. However, some courageous members got together and managed to get a Stay Order from High Court on the sale of flats in Bluebell. The big question is: why did MCGM not take any action to stop this daylight robbery, which happened during the tenure of Municipal Commissioner Jairaj Phatak and Chief Minister Ashok Chavan?

6. Ongoing theft of electricity and water from the completed buildings for the under-construction buildings. In May 2011, a major short circuit and fire happened in the meter room of Vinca building. This incident revealed that electricity was directly being tapped from the underground cable of Reliance Energy, and the unauthorized cable was connected to an under-construction building in this Chandivali township. The fire brigade, however, has not yet issued its report after the incident, and Reliance Energy also has not pursued the matter further, despite follow-up by the angry residents. Similarly, the residents of Lilium and Lantana buildings recently discovered that municipal water from their building was being used for the construction work of a neighbouring building, and made a commotion. However, the municipal authorities have not initiated any action against the builder. The builder has evidently hushed up the matter with the fire brigade, Reliance Energy officials and MCGM officials.  Such theft would not be possible if a cooperative society were in charge of the building. 

7. Collection of 18 months maintenance in advance. Nahar Builders & Developers charges each flat monthly maintenance of about Rs 18,000 per quarter, even if it is unoccupied. The residents and investors are asked to make advance payment for 18 months as a lumpsum i.e. Rs. 1.08 lakhs. There is no accountability for this. In the instance of one building, Nahar raised a fresh demand for payment within one year, saying that the advance payment had been consumed by expenses.

8. Charging exorbitant transfer fees in return for NOC to sell. Builder Sukhraj B Nahar is a clever man, who understands the mentality of his customers. He understands that rather than put up a fight in courts, many of these people would prefer to sell their house and leave. And that gives him another opportunity to twist their arms. Although they are owners of the property, they are not allowed to sell it, because Nahar insists that they should first get his No Objection Certificate (NOC) – which is not required by law. For giving NOC, he demands a rate of Rs 500 to Rs 1000 per sq. ft. (Super Built Up). On a typical flat admeasuring 1500 sq ft, this means Rs 7.5 to 15 lakhs. He usually collects this amount in cash, but in case someone insists on a cheque payment, Nahar permits “voluntary donation” to the S B Nahar Charitable Trust in exchange for an NOC. See a specimen here: http://tinyurl.com/SB-Nahar-Charity-Trust-Receipt  (This is an illegal fee. A cooperative society can charge a maximum of Rs 25,000 as transfer fees. The builder is actually not authorized to charge transfer fees at all. Even if one assumes that the builder is acting on behalf of the cooperative society that will eventually be formed, he cannot charge more than Rs 25,000.) Even if you wish to give your house on lease, rent or leave-and-license, the builder insists that you need his NOC, which of course comes at a heavy price.

9. Cheating with properties that are already sold. S B Nahar does not like second-sales of his flats since he wants to control the price of his apartments. He insists that all sales of flats should happen through his sales staff and has set up another broker company called Property Lounge. His staff persuades the prospective seller to hand over the keys to the flat, by promising to sell the flats and remit money to their bank account within 7 days. People don’t hesitate, as this is an accepted practice when one appoints an estate agent to dispose off one’s properties. But after that, the seller finds it extremely difficult to get back his own house keys!

10. Cheating investors. About 4 years ago, when Nahar Builders & Developers announced the bookings of two buildings named Water Lily and White Lily, 700 flats were sold at the rate of Rs 5,500 within 28 days. Surprised at his own success, the builder had second thoughts about his rates. And so, he called all the investors back and refunded all the token cheques of Rs 2-3 lakhs each, saying that MCGM had not approved his plans. Three months later, Nahar announced fresh bookings at the hiked-up rate of Rs 9000, and sold all the flats at this new rate – effectively cheating about 700 investors of their gains. 

11. Fraudulently getting Occupation Certificate. MCGM gives occupation certificates (OCs) for half-complete buildings of Nahar. MCGM also lets him change the names of his buildings in the OCs by pen, and backs him up if he is challenged. See these photos taken the backyard of buildings that have been given occupation certificates:  http://tinyurl.com/Nahar-Amrit-Shakti-photos 


The residents of these buildings belong to the empowered class of society. These are prestigious people who can afford to shell out more than a crore rupees per 2 BHK flat. But most of these people don’t have the temperament to fight a bully builder.  Large numbers of the residents of Nahar’s Amrit Shakti properties are afraid of the builder’s uniformed maintenance men and security guards swarming all over the massive compounds and the gates. If you are blacklisted by Nahar, you and your family members will find it difficult to enter your own apartment in these heavily guarded compounds. So it is better to buy peace-of-mind by living quietly within your four walls according to the rules that the builder makes for you.

Many investors are NRIs – rich and powerful abroad, but with limited capability to fight a legal battle in the Indian courts. Hundreds of NRIs were lured into buying flats at Nahar Amrit Shakti apartment sales, held in property fairs organized by HDFC’s branches abroad in Dubai and London. 

So HDFC (a premium real estate institution whose chairman is industry captain Deepak Parekh, who sits on many government committees) is an exclusive partner in Nahar’s Amrit Shakti project. On page 16 of the Nahar Amrit Shakti brochure (http://tinyurl.com/HDFC-involvement-in-Nahar-Hsg), it clearly states, “Much of Nahar Group’s success can be attributed to HDFC”. Using HDFC’s backing, Nahar goes on to claim the support of a couple of dozen other financial institutions as well on the next page. This is misleading.


HDFC’S EXCLUSIVE TIE-UP WITH S B NAHAR IS AT MANY LEVELS:

a) HDFC Bank’s direct loan to Nahar. Onwards from 2005, HDFC has given project finance of several hundred crore rupees to Nahar Builders and Developers to enable this massive township project to get off the ground. When a flat buyer takes an HDFC home loan for purchase of a flat at Nahar’s Amrit Shakti, the HDFC’s loan to the builder gets paid back by the people who have taken a loan from HDFC to buy the house. In other words, HDFC acts as if it is a part owner of this Nahar’s township. Has HDFC considered the conflict of interest such an arrangement suffers? Isn’t HDFC now willingly overlooking the builder’s wrongdoings and criminal acts in order to recover its stake in the project?

b) HDFC Realty Ltd is a major estate broker of this Nahar township. HDFC’s estate broking arm HDFC Realty Ltd is actively promoting Nahar Amrit Shakti flats. Despite knowing that Nahar imposes illegal transfer charges and indulges in numerous other malpractices, HDFC Realty’s agents never inform buyers about these issues at the time of buying the flat. If you search on HDFC Realty’s website for properties in Powai worth over Rs 1 crore, almost all the search results shown are Nahar properties in Chandivali. (Note: The website shows amenities like “Pool, Children Play Area, Gym, Club house, Jogging Track”. This is a completely false claim. Although buyers have been getting possession of their flats since 2008, the clubhouse, jogging tracks etc. remain at a rudimentary stage of construction.)

c) HDFC Bank’s overseas branches display Nahar Amrit Shakti brochures. Thanks to this tie-up, Nahar enjoys the brand equity of HDFC among NRIs who would never have heard of this dubious builder, had it not been for HDFC promoting this project all over the world. HDFC has ended up acting as Nahar’s contact point with unwary investors enthralled by India’s success story.

d) HDFC employees collude with Nahar builder. People who purchased a flat in Nahar Amrit Shakti with HDFC home loans find that even HDFC office staff write letters and emails insisting on Nahar’s NOC before transferring the loan to the buyer’s name. Thus, they knowingly participate in this illegality. 


Are these sorts of blatant wrongdoing also happening in other massive housing complexes and townships-HDFC, which are essentially gated communities run by builders rather than cooperative societies? One doesn’t know, because the people who live in gated communities rarely come together to discuss these things, and builders enjoy an unusually free hand in running the show. There aren’t too many forums for investors, customers and residents to publicly review or give feedback on these things. Also, there aren’t too many real estate agents who give honest opinions or reviews.

In the case of Nahar’s Amrit Shakti in Powai, we know of these things because a handful of courageous individuals have decided to come out into the open… and fight for their rights.

If you are one of the victims of this massive scam, which affects over 4,000 families, please don’t remain silent and buy peace. Now is the time to speak up and join the fight for truth and justice.

Warmly,
Krish
98215 88114
thebravepedestrian@gmail.com

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Friends, Put Aside Your Negative Beliefs & Apply for Central Information Commissioner’s Post

It is said that people deserve the government that they get. We are not suppressed by the politicians and bureaucrats; we are suppressing ourselves, and allowing corruption to prevail.

Our mindset is: “I shall criticize the driver, but I shall never take the driving seat.”

After losing a second appeal hearing, we come out of the information commissioner’s office cursing his ignorance of RTI, and his biased mindset. We blame him for being pro-PIO, because he is a former bureaucrat or a politician’s chamcha. We say that he is insensitive to the plight of the struggling RTI activist. We say that the only way things can only change if civil society members, and not bureaucrats, start becoming information commissioners.

But, now that Govt. of India has called civil society candidates to apply for the post of Central Information Commissioner (last date to apply is 18 November), what happens? Are we applying? Or are we encouraging others, whom we consider knowledgeable and intelligent, to apply?

 A BIG NO! Everybody is thanda! I spoke to a number of RTI activists in many states a couple of days ago, and what did I hear?

MOST COMMON REPLIES:

1) “Information commissioner? Who me? No way! I will do a better job staying outside the system and being an RTI activist.” 
(Translated, this means: “I will always criticize the cooking, but never go into the kitchen and try preparing anything myself.”)

2) “It is an honorary position, and I can’t afford to move to Delhi and do an honorary job.” 
(Hey hello!!! Sir! Madam! The job of CIC is NOT AN HONORARY POSITION. It carries a very respectable pay packet of about Rs 1.3 lakh per month, plus benefits. A CIC is directly appointed by President of India after selection by a three-member selection committee chaired by Prime Minister. I am not saying you should apply because of the money or the prestige, but please be aware of what you are so casually turning down!)

3) “My business/profession/present lifestyle is too important. I can’t leave it and go to Delhi.” 
(Is this what I hear from the CEO of some big company? No, I hear it from normal, middle-class guys like you and me — who may be earning Rs 30-40,000 per month. Maybe a lot less. Have we collectively lost it?!)

4) “We should motivate some good and intelligent persons to apply.” 
(To which I reply, “Very good, Sir. Please name one such good and intelligent person, and let us talk to him”. And they are like, “Uh… uh… I can’t think of anybody in my circle. Maybe somebody outside my circle… someone unknown to me… maybe.” So it appears that we RTI activists don’t keep very good company!) 

5) “The post is only for great and important people. I am a very ordinary man.” 
(Yeah… as if the information commissions are all full of “great people”. At this point, we conveniently forget that we regularly call CICs complete idiots and spineless chamchas. Now that we are asked to apply for the job, we suddenly get an inferiority complex, and these idiots suddenly become “great people”!)

6) “Become an information commissioner? Why bother? It will fail anyway. Instead, we should file a PIL against the corrupt government and make it clean. Otherwise, nothing will happen, and things will go on like this.” 
(Translation: “Why attempt to reform the system little by little? Why should you and I do all that hard work? Let us instead think about a great big pie-in-the-sky and feel happy. Or better still, let us depend on someone like Anna Hazare to drop down from the heavens and reform the system all at once!”)

7) “I don’t run after power and position. I am a humble person, and a quiet worker.” 
(This reply implies that anybody who applies for the position of information commissioner is running after power and position… and therefore, he is an greedy person. I am speechless before this reply, because if I say that I will apply, I will be considered a bad person too!)

But thank God, I heard positive replies from some people, and these replies lifted my spirits. Some good people said that they had already applied, and a couple of them had received email confirmation from DoPT.

PLEASE UNDERSTAND THIS:

A. If WE don’t apply, we are leaving the field open for political appointments and nepotism. It is necessary for large numbers of us to apply, so that proper eligibility criteria and selection procedure is put in place.

B. We should not have an inferiority complex before bureaucrats. Many of us in civil society are at least as competent as ex-IAS officers. There is a joke among bureaucrats that an IAS officer loses one vertebra per year of service; so, after 33 years of service, he becomes completely spineless, and is able to bend in whichever direction his political masters want him to. Presumably, we  civil-society-wallahs have a backbone… or do we?

C. There are about 11 posts of Central Information Commissioners (including the chief). Even if only one third are filled by civil society members, that means CIVIL SOCIETY MUST PUT UP AT LEAST 3-4 REALLY GOOD CANDIDATES EVERY FIVE YEARS FOR CIC’S POST. And if we can’t even do this, shame on us!

D. To extend the same logic to State Information Commissions, there should be about 150 State Information Commissioners in 28 states to avoid buildup of pendency. (There are currently around 80, but there were 106 in 2009-10.) RTI implementation will improve if even one-third of these are from civil society. This means each state information commission requires at least 1-2 good quality civil society candidates every 5 years. SO WE NEED 40-50 CIVIL SOCIETY CANDIDATES FOR THE STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER’S POST EVERY FIVE YEARS.

Please apply for CIC’s post now. This is an opportunity for you to show the babus how administration should be done. ALSO, THIS IS YOUR CHANCE TO GENUINELY SERVE 10-15 RTI ACTIVISTS & WHISTLE-BLOWERS EVERY WORKING DAY FOR THE NEXT FIVE YEARS. Do you think you can achieve this by being an RTI activist?

If you don’t apply, political cronies who have no love for RTI activists will be appointed as CICs. They will disappoint and frustrate thousands of RTI activists and information seekers, and they will diminish people’s faith in Right to Information for the next five years. Please don’t let this happen. Believe in yourself and do your best.

TO MAKE YOUR APPLICATION, download this word (.doc) file: http://tinyurl.com/format-4-CIC-applications 

As a SAMPLE OF HOW YOUR APPLICATION WILL LOOK after you are finished, see this application made by my colleague Mohd Afzal: http://tinyurl.com/Mohd-Afzal-CIC-Application 


Email the completed forms to usrti-dopt@nic.in before November 18. Preferably, do it today. I promise you, I will!

Warm Regards,
Krish
98215 88114

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future, RTI Act 2005, Right to Information.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Oppose Further Congestion of Mumbai. Send this letter to Chief Minister & Municipal Commissioner

Dear fellow Mumbaikars,

Happy Diwali. Let us start this year auspiciously by raising our voices to protect our Sampada or shared wealth.

While we are celebrating the destruction of mythological, the modern-day demons are feasting on our common wealth, unchecked. While we pray for our individual prosperity (Sampatti), our government is selling our precious public spaces to modern-day Ravanas. Maharashtra Government has decided to gift our last remaining open spaces to builders, by raising FSI by 33 percent… and nobody has yet raised a voice to oppose this!

Our public spaces in Mumbai belong to us, our children and grandchildren, and to the common man who toils in silence to earn his daily bread. We the People need these basic minimum spaces for our health and sanity, and our quality of life. Open spaces are not the government’s property; it is not a commodity that the government can sell to raise money. 

Please speak up. If we remain silent even when this grave injustice is done, we are unworthy of the protection of Lord Rama and the blessings of Goddess Lakshmi. If our love for comfort is so great that we cannot even write a letter to our elected government, then we don’t deserve our freedom and democracy. Please don’t commit the sin of silence.

Tomorrow, we will POST THE BELOW LETTER TO THE CHIEF MINISTER & MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER. Please email grvora1@gmail.com to include your name in the list of signatories.

Kindly send the following details for inclusion in this letter:
Name of your ALM, NGO or association (if any)
Name of your area (e.g. Mankhurd)
Your contact phone number (optional but preferable)

You may also print this letter on your own letterhead and send it. Download word file of draft: http://tinyurl.com/Oppose-33-FSI-Mumbai-letter 

Warm Regards,
GR Vora & Krish
98215 88114
———————————————————————————–
DRAFT OF LETTER

27 October 2011

To
Mr Prithviraj Chavan,
Chief Minister of Maharashtra,
Mantralaya, Madame Cama Road,
Mumbai 400032

33% Increase in FSI will congest this city, destroy the last shreds of our quality of life

Dear Sir,

We note with alarm that you have cleared a proposal for a 33% increase in floor space index, letting builders put up taller buildings, or add floors to existing projects. The dailies say that you believe that the existing infrastructure can support this extra 33%. (One news item: http://tinyurl.com/33-Extra-FSI ) Your advisors seem to have told you that this increase in FSI is good for Mumbai’s people, as the premium earned from the FSI will help you raise more funds for infrastructure projects, to ultimately improve the quality of life.

Sir, you have been wrongly advised. Allowing further vertical growth of this city will increase the density of human and vehicle population, thereby increasing congestion at ground level. You cannot improve quality of life by increasing congestion, no matter what clever arguments are used to justify it. The only beneficiaries of your decision, Sir, will be builders and their investors.

Mumbai has the about one-tenth of the minimum per capita open space that a city should have. Like fresh air and water, open spaces are a key requirement for physical and mental health. Protecting open spaces is a constitutional duty of your government, as it is part of our fundamental right to life and liberty. You cannot barter away our life and liberty for raising government revenues.

Sir, space cannot be created; it is limited and non-renewable, and consuming the existing space drastically reduces our quality of life. This loss cannot be compensated by any other infrastructure.

Although traffic flyovers, foot over bridges (FOBs) and other facilities have been built in recent years, the quality of life is deteriorating alarmingly. Footpaths, shop frontages, usable road margins, recreation grounds and the compounds of private buildings are vanishing under the pressure of increasing numbers of people, private vehicles, hawkers, encroachers and the debris of construction works. Sir, we cannot walk and breathe! 

UP-MARKET AREAS WHERE LIFE IS HELL FOR MUMBAI’S CITIZENS:

1) SOUTH MUMBAI NEIGHBOURHOODS. The neighbourhood of CM’s bungalow, Malabar Hill, is possibly the best in the city, where residents enjoy non-stop water supply and power supply. But the compounds, garages and roads are overflowing with parked cars. There are barely any useable footpaths. The residential buildings are overflowing with full time domestic helpers and drivers, who sleep in the corridors and garages. Children cannot even walk unescorted outside their compounds, and have no space to play inside their compounds. There is no space for senior citizens to take a stroll or sit on benches. The story is the same in the posh areas of Colaba and Marine Lines. 

Life in Marine Lines is tolerable only because of its nearness to the Marine Drive promenade, but constant traffic noise from Marine Drive drains the health and sanity of people living there. Traffic jams happen daily in all these places. Sir, is this what your advisors term as adequate infrastructure? Is this the benchmark for upgrading the rest of Mumbai? If so, the future is bleak indeed.

2) WESTERN SUBURBS. Bandra West and Andheri West are areas where many celebrities live and work. Today, these places are commuters’ nightmares, even at non-peak hours. 

3) EASTERN SUBURBS. Not so long ago, Ghatkopar and Chembur used to be considered good residential neighbourhoods. Today, the street conditions are horrible, and even non-peak traffic crawls slower than a walking person. 

INADEQUATE INFRASTRUCTURE IS THE NORM IN MUMBAI:

a) ROADSIDES & FOOT OVERBRIDGES. Sir, throughout the city and suburbs, elderly persons and children cannot even walk by the side of the roads, and they cannot cross the roads. Over 90 per cent of the roads have no footpaths or even decent road margins. Many FOBs are two or three storey’s high, which many senior citizens are unable to climb. Senior citizens and people with disabilities are forced to travel by private vehicles or stay at home.

b) PUBLIC TRANSPORT – BUSES AND RAILWAYS. Getting into public transport at peak hours is like wrestling, which only able-bodied persons can do. The savage conditions in which people are forced to travel are unacceptable, even by third-world country standards. Senior citizens are unable to use even the bus-stops and suburban railway stations, leave alone the buses and trains!

c) WATER SUPPLY & POWER. Sir, the government is unable to even provide sufficient water to existing residents of Mumbai. Thousands of buildings are at the mercy of the water-tanker lobby and bottled water suppliers. Mumbai enjoys 24 x 7 power supply, only because you are unduly depriving other towns and villages of Maharashtra. We don’t have sufficient power and water supply for diversion to construction activity. Also, the people living and working in newly constructed buildings will add to the existing demand for power and water. This is unacceptable!

Sir, the builder lobby and their friends in the establishment have created twisted justifications for further congesting our city, for their own profits. Please do not be taken in by such false reasoning.

THE BOTTOMLINE IS: 

A. INCREASE THE AVAILABILITY OF CLEAN AND CLEAR SPACES for walking, bicycling, crossing roads, playing and other activities for a good quality of life. No more promises; do it now!

B. ENSURE THAT PUBLIC TRANSPORT IS ACCESSIBLE TO EVERY CITIZEN, especially those who are aged and physically challenged, at all hours. No more promises; do it now!

C. UNTIL YOU MAKE PROGRESS ON THE ABOVE TWO PARAMETERS, please halt construction activities in Mumbai city and suburbs. No more promises; do it now!

Yours sincerely,
Your signature, name, details and contact nos.

Copy to Mr Subodh Kumar, Municipal Commissioner, MCGM, Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai.

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Our Future.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments



Satire: How Citizens’ Candidates & Good-People’s Party will clean up Corruption

Dear friends,

Suddenly, busy people who never had the time to even participate in the running of their own building cooperative society are eager to run the government. Everybody wants to be a Citizen’s Candidate for the 2012 municipal elections in Mumbai, and they all have one thing in mind: eradicating corruption. 

And so they are forming parties. 

My friends Anand and Babita were having this conversation some days back, while I was literally a fly on the wall. A lot of people are having these conversations nowadays, and that’s why this is so significant.

Anand: Things can’t go on like this. We must reform our nation, which is corrupt and badly governed.
o Babita: Yes I totally agree. I feel horrible when I read the newspapers. India is such a badly managed country! So much garbage and pollution! Not like America and Singapore and all…

Anand: Almost every leader is corrupt to the core. Good governance cannot happen as long as the present lot is around.
o Babita: Absolutely!

Anand: All these leaders should be voted out of office, and replaced by a better lot.
o Babita: Yes, but who to vote for? All the politicians in Congress, BJP, Samajwadi Party etc. are also corrupt goons.

Anand: Exactly! But you and I are not corrupt. They should have people like us.
o Babita: Yes. Even if I someone offered me hundreds of crores for selling 2G bandwidth, I would refuse. You know me… I am not a not dirty person like Raja and Kalmadi and Yedyurappa and… 

Anand: That is why you and I must become part of the establishment. Without fighting elections, we cannot make a difference.
o Babita: True. Nobody listens to the common man in India.

Anand: Right. So let us contest the municipal elections in 2012, become corporators and clean  up the city.
o Babita: But who will vote for us? Only a handful of people know me even in my own cooperative housing society! I don’t want to be in my society’s managing committee, because you know, they are such unreasonable and corrupt people… and where is the time for me to get into stuff like collecting maintenance, paying property taxes and dealing with tank cleaning contractors? I don’t like getting into jhamelas! But if somebody else does the groundwork, then I will participate and give my ideas.

Anand: Don’t worry, just stay focused on the main thing. Let us – you and I – form a citizens’ political party, and become their candidates. Our citizens’ political party will select us, naturally. So we are Citizen’s Candidates. Other citizens will vote for us because we are decent people like them… because we are not dirty politicians.
o Babita: Ok. But I hope I won’t have to go and campaign for myself. I hate to go to neighbourhood buildings, and all those slums, and meet the smelly people who live there in those damp little houses, and request them to vote for me. We will need their votes, but I don’t want to talk to them. Chh-eeee! Yuckkkk!

Anand: We shouldn’t go around asking for votes. How will it look if I go and ask people to vote for me? No way I want to do that! So let us make a party of good people like you and me, and they will go and campaign for us and distribute pamphlets and everything. We screen out the bad people who are not like us, and who may cause trouble later. Only 227 out of the thousands of good people in our party will stand for 2012 elections; the remaining will selflessly support the 227 candidates, and in return, we will support them when they stand for parliamentary elections of 2014.
o Babita: You mean that in 2014, we will have to go walking in the slums and asking for votes? Yuck! The only slum people whom I can tolerate are my kaam-wali-bai, my driver, the doodh-wala and the watchman. But I hope you will never let my kaam-wali join our party.

Anand: No no, don’t worry. I’ll ask you before admitting anybody to our party. No smelly people with dirty shirts and hawaii slippers will join our party. Only good people who have good tuning with you and me. And we will tell everybody to approach five good people and request for donations.
o Babita: Yeah! Suppose even one thousand people donate ten thousand rupees each, that means a campaign fund of Rs 10 lakh for my election campaign!

Anand: So you will also donate Rs 10,000 for my campaign fund, right?
o Babita: Of course! But wait till everybody else donates. If you still have a shortage, I will make my donation. But I will have to ask my husband first, and see what he says. 

Anand: Next Sunday, I have called a meeting of some good people at my house. You must come.
o Mr. B: Why Sunday? Sunday is the only day I get to spend time with my family.

Anand: Arre yaar, even my wife said the same thing. But nobody will come to our meetings on weekdays. Everybody is busy with their naukri-dhandha. Only on Sunday’s they will find some time. 
o Babita: Ok, fine, I’ll come.

Anand: We will have to work hard for the next few months, till the elections. You must come for meetings every Sunday. Promise me!
o Babita: Yeah, fine. But only until the elections are over, Ok? I have my own life, yaar! I don’t want to be doing netagiri all my life! And another thing, I don’t want all mannerless party workers in my sitting room, walking all over my carpets with their chappals and ruining my sofas. So don’t call any meetings at my place, ok?

Anand: Ok, stop worrying. After the elections, everything will return to normal. Trust me.
o Babita: And corruption will be gone? 

Anand: Yeah, so after we become corporators, we will make the roads and footpaths nice and clean. And we will tell all hawkers to be gone. No haftas, no nothing.
o Babita: First thing I do is tell the municipality-wallahs to demolish all those slums and remove all encroachments. And then I will tell the Prime Minister and Chief Minister that I won’t tolerate corruption in my area. And I will tell all the police inspectors and havaldars to do their job and put the corrupt people behind bars. I won’t tolerate any hank-panky. If any BJP or Sena corporator gets fresh with me, I’ll give him a piece of my mind, just you see!

With so many citizens’ candidates and good people’s parties jumping into the fray, the days of corrupt politicians are numbered. Anand and Babita and their Good People’s Party will do a better job of governance than Manmohan and Sonia and who-have-you. 

Watch out, India! Watch out, Mumbai! Anand and Babita are here, and they are unstoppable!

Warm Regards,
Krish
98215 88114

Posted in Activism, Governance & Administration, Indian Society, Our Future.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

No comments