Skip to content


Mankol–my grandfather’s village

I visited Mankol, my grandfather Ambalal Sarabhai’s village, today. He had built the main square, and an 8 kilometre brick lake there from where the village gets a lot of its water. He had renovated the Bootmata temple.
He is much adored there and so was I. In 1926 he gave the village a harmonium which they still use for their many plays. (How ironical that the harmonium was announced as my election symbol just yesterday!)

The village has 9000 people and is the main of 24 villages. What started as a meeting with the leaders turned into a walk through the village, and later I addressed a couple of hundred people from dadaji’s porch.

Prices are killing the farmers. Women have all the usual problems. Narmada water is available for farming but not for drinking yet.

Posted in Campaign.

4 comments


Jubilations along the way


The village of Juval in Sanand taluka is angry with the sops that the Nano project has got from the government, when they don’t even get proper power through the day. The power is intermittent and short-circuits very often, while the industries get power all the time. I met about 100 women, 50 men and more than a 100 children. The men also said that the water from the Narmada canal was depleting the fertility of their soil.

Another matter that came up during my discussions with them was the government plan of giving wheat at Rs 2 per kilo. They said the quality was so bad that they would not even consider feeding it to their cattle!

When it was time to go, I saw the group of women getting ready to go away too, and found upon asking, they were going to the next village to sing. I asked them to sing for me and they demanded that I sing for them first! So I did, and they joined in and there was such jubilation. They promised to come as a mandali and sing when I get elected!

Posted in Campaign.

No comments


Asmita group takes a role


We kicked off the arts communication campaign yesterday in Juhapura with Arvind Gaur’s Asmita, a hugely talented group of youngsters. They spent an hour with me understanding all the issues that I have come to understand from my interactions with over 100 villages and more areas in the city, and then stayed up all night and wrote a street theatre piece. The women completely forgot that they were actors and startedarguing vociferously with them!


Posted in Campaign.

No comments


Om Puri and Arvind Gaur join the campaign

The veteran actor Om Puri was here today, campaigning with us, urging voters to recognise that I would be the right candidate to represent Gandhinagar. The versatile actor, who has known me and my work for many years now, got great response. He specially urged women and young people to go out and vote and exercise their right as citizens.

We also have Delhi-based theatre specialist Arvind Gaur, who with his team are performing all over the city talking about issues which need to be raised, issues which need to be solved. Their support is very encouraging.

Today we went all over Usmanpura, Gokulnagar Society, the Riverfront jhopadpatti, the Asia Pacific Management Institute, and met over 1000 people. In the afternoon, we took a Peace March from Vejalpur to Juhapura in which about 5000-6000 people participated.

Late evening, a public rally is arranged at Ranip, from the Bus Stop to the Pani-ki-Tanki where we will have a meeting.

Every day, there is much activity. We are now waiting for our symbol to come on April 13th.




Posted in Blogs.

4 comments


500 families may be homeless soon

In Indira Nagar Chhapra in Kalol, 500 families are facing demolition of their homes, to make way for a garden. The bull dozers were ready to raze them, and they were not even given any notice to remove their belongings.

A stay order in the high court has stopped it for the time being. But one never knows.

The uncertainty is hanging in the air. I felt it as I walked through the entire colony.

There are those who believe that anyone occupying land should be removed from it. Then what? Where will they go? Why are they here? Have we taken care of the problem?

Why would anyone want to leave their own homes to come and live like this? Think about it.



Posted in Development.

1 comment


Meeting Idris


I met Idris in the hutments across Sector 28 in Gandhinagar. This is a slum I pass frequently, for the villages where I have been working for many years are beyond them. Today, and for many years they have been out of work, going and standing at the chowki to be picked up as daily labourers. In spite of being across the road from the Gujarat Electricity Board, there are no lights. No toilets. No water connections. Enough dust to make us choke.
After speaking with a group of a hundred people i saw a young man chewing tobacco. I went up to him and said that cancer wasn’t worth the relief that the chewing provided. I offered to take him to the cancer museum that the Civil Hospital runs — after the election. Another young man was talking about the lack of jobs. I am a driver he said, but I have had no work for years. I turned and asked if he had a valid license. Yes, I was told. Then give me your
phone number as I need chauffeurs fro the campaign, I told him. “When you hear my name, you won’t want me. I am a Muslim”. “It makes no difference to me” I said. He burst into tears. “I have lost forty jobs in three years because I am called Idris”. He has joined the campaign
and is also a fantastic drummer. At this moment he is dressing to dance in the “Mallikabenno Sannedo”!

Posted in Governance.

1 comment


How useful is a school without a teacher or a hospital without a staff?


Looking at the apparent infrastructure of the health care system
in Gujarat one would be fooled into thinking all is well. As compared
to the norms of how many Primary Health Centres or Community Health
Centres or Sub Centres are needed per thousand people, Gujarat is
bursting with health. But go slightly deeper into what staff is
available is available and one gets a totally different picture. Form
my tramping through the villages and slums of my constituency this
discrepancy is appearing more and more frequently. Tackling this with
motivated and trained staff is a conundrum which would have to be
solved.
Table 2: Health Infrastructure in Gujarat as on March 2007
Particulars Required In-position Shortfall
Sub-center 7263 7274 0
Primary Health Center (PHC) 1172 1073 99
Community Health Center (CHC) 293 273 20
Health worker Female/ANM at sub-center 7274 7071 203
Health worker Female/ANM at sub-center & PHC 8347 7071 1276
Health Worker Male at subcenters 7274 3347 3927
Doctor at PHC 1073 1034 3

Surgeons at CHCs                                            
       273       70 307

Obstetricians & Gynaecologists at CHCs
273 6 267
Physicians at CHC 273 0 273
Paediatricians at CHCs 273 6 267
Total specialists at CHCs 1092 82 1010
Radiographers 273 124 149
Pharmacist 1346 814 532
Laboratory Technicians 1346 899 447
Nurse/Midwife 2984 1585 1399
Source: Rural Health Statistics Bulletin, March 2007





Posted in Public health.

4 comments


Why?


After visits in and around the Gandhinagar constituency, my list of “Why?” keeps increasing every day…
- Why is there no PHC in Jalund village?
- Why is there no ST service in Moti Adraj?
 - Why are there  no toilets in Borij?
 - Why has a tank in Ghatlodia - that is said to have cost Rs. 60 lakhs- never had a drop of water?
 - Why are there only 32 polling booths for 2 lakh people in Juhapura?
 - Why are there no gutters in Borisana?
 - Why is NREGA not applicable in Sonawada?
- Why do villagers in Gokulpura have to walk a 15 km circuitous route when a 3 km road could ease their transport problems?

Why?
It would be too simple to answer all these questions with “Its because the local authorities are inefficient”. Of course, there is a certain level of inefficiency that is only too obvious to those who talk to villagers around Gandhinagar. But the answer to these questions goes beyond issues of the local authorites being inefficient, to asystem that is inherently flawed. A system that once aware of such inefficiency can choose not to address them!

What is worse is how often the same questions are repeated across villages and talukas. Questions that have been around for years and have still not been answered. Questions that have led all those who ask them to believe that the answers will never come. Questions that reiterate the fact that in Indian politics today, the same mistakes are being repeated again and again. And again.

As I talk to more people and add to my list of “Why this?” and “Why that?”, I become more certain in the need for a new kind of leadership.
A leadership that, if nothing else, will bring back a belief that asking questions can lead to getting answers. A leadership that believes in honing its ideas based on what its people most need. A leadership therefore that revels in taking new risks and making new mistakes.


Posted in Governance.

9 comments


We remain where we were


The Valmiki Ambedkar Awas Yojana (VAMBAY) is a Centre-State partnership scheme to provide homes and improve the living conditions of slum households. But while it might be a good idea in theory, its practical application leaves a lot to be desired.
On a recent visit to Vejalpur, we received a lot of complaints about VAMBAY and upon further investigation with locals and NGOS, realised the convoluted nature of the problem.

As per the housing initiative in the area, members of a certain locality were given homes for which they had to pay Rs 600 a month in rent. Of course this figure did not include electricity and maintenance — including which their rent amounted to about Rs 800 per month. This might not seem like much, but when this figure is increased by adding to it food and school and medical expenses, there is not much left  of the Rs 2000 - 2500  monthly income that a lot of the residents here earn.

What is the solution? That more of the VAMBAY grant is used to lighten the monetary burden of rent on these families. However, since their income of Rs 2500 a month doesn’t really “qualify” them as being as needy as necessary, further grants cannot be applied to them. So, without the assistance of the scheme, the members of the community default on rent,  their houses are taken away from them and are now left locked up without use. Everybody loses.

There are so many Centre schemes and State schemes and Centre-State schemes in India today, and yet when one looks into their application, it is a sad case. Schemes are written with many clauses and sub clauses. No one tells their target population what these clauses and sub clauses are. We all operate on some vague knowledge of what is supposed to happen without ever having a clear idea of the facts. The government obfuscates, the people meander about in a confused fashion, and at the end of the day, hardly anything gets done.

We remain exactly where we were the day before.


Posted in Governance.

3 comments