I was a judge for the national IRIS fair this year in Pune. It is a joint initiative between CII, DST (GoI) and Intel, and continuing for
many years now. I have been associated with it in one way or other for
4-5 years now, but the first time I am going as a judge in the national
fair. There were about 15 of us in the Judges category covering various
subjects ranging from computer science and environmental science to
maths and physics. The participants are either class 5 to 7 students or
class 8 to 12 students. There is a fairly rigorous process to enter,
starting from submission of synposis, its screening, feedback,
mentoring, etc. There are subject category prizes and special mention
prizes, and the main prize of representing India in the international
version of the fair, this time in Atlanta. I think, Intel bears all the
expenses for the trip for the child and a guardian.
It is interesting to see the enthu among the kids. There is a lot of grooming
- so most of them talk polished English, well rehearsed. Unfortunately,
there is too much pressure being applied on the system, with parents
and guides desperate to win the prize at any cost. So, cut and paste
from the net is not uncommon - and it takes away a good part of the
judging time to eliminate them from the short list. Guides/parents
doing bulk of the work is also not very rare.
It is unfortunate that these events are not reaching the vast number of schools in India. No institution can spend
enough money to enhance the outreach beyond a
point. We need more ambassadors of this program at every nook and
corner. Interesting and brilliant ideas do come from all of these
places. The Metro culture tend to think in an imitating style, bringing
in more of the same type of projects. For example, every year, there is
a class of extraction projects. Take some natural substance say X
(plants, paper (wasted), weeds, fruit peels, etc) and extract some
useful chemical Y from it (mosquito repellent, cockroach control,
thermocol, plastic, various chemical compounds, etc). You will see them
in various X-Y combinations. Energy is another popular topic with
various innovations in exploiting solar power (as electricity, heat,
etc) and wind power. There was even a project which gathers the heat
generated by the burning coconuts in Sabarimala temple and produce
electricity from that.
At times due to the pressure factor,
there is a tendency to defend things without knowing - something that
gets me irritated often! And lack of adequate mentoring is also often
seen - resulting in a lot of effort being put in, but not reaching any
useful results. If someone could get these kids to think further, probe
further, etc by asking them the right questions, they would go far. I
found this in many cases - if you point out a flaw in their work, they
are open to think over and suggest, often sensible, solutions. We need
to do this more often…
On the whole a nice experience…. The
enthu on the students” faces is nice to see, coupled with the innocence
of their age. Wonder how many of them will retain! This year the theme
was the power of “Q” - questioning. “Einstein had the power of Q” - say
posters in the halls. Of course, they also had big banners on all
vehicles and roads declaring “geniuses inside - drive carefully” or
“geniuses on the move” -' I thought this was going far. We should
reward, recognise and encourage - but in a limit appropriate to the
nature of achievement. Overdoing it will create negative impact.