1630 India
Two articles appeared on Sunday side by side. One was on History and Historians and other on Archives of British India. First one was by Sanjay Sonavani who has systematically elaborated the abilities and responsibilities of Historians .Dwelling on the issue he argues that history has propensity to get hijacked by politicians and that facts tend to get distorted if there is a bias in the mind of the Historian towards specific personalities and cult.
He works out a case in the Maratha History about the dispute as to who was Shivajis Guru or tutor? The plain truth is that he might have had none.For actually Shivaji was a self made man and then there were no schools or colleges at the time although there was Guru Shishya Parampara but due the instability in the life of child Shivaji any formal education was impossible and unheard of. Also Shivaji indigenously developed the art and science of Guerilla warfare which was a method adopted by him by default and not with any particular design or prior policy being innocent about the theory of a administered battle philosophy or war game. It was just similar down to earth confrontation tactic like that adopted by David when his adversary was Goliath and the sling was a perfect weapon.
Interestingly both these stories were in our school syllabus ;that of David versus Goliath and the Childhood Training of Shivaji by Dodoji Kondev.Dadoji was Jagirdar of Deccan under Bijapur Sultans .He was an able general who probably trained Shahajis son informally in basic skills as swordmanship and horse riding due to mere proximity of the child and having necessary resources at his disposal to award him few lessons .Again, whether Dadoji had any vested interest to potentiate Shivaji would be another area of research like that of Chanakya who trained and tutored Chandragupta against Dhanannand
There is another school of thought which was doing the rounds : that Sant or Swami Ramdas was another Guru of Shivaji.There is no evidence to support this .The swami was a staunch ascetic and nationalist and devotee of Lord Ram .He had composed practical philosophical verse named Dasbodh .This philosophy was coincidently congruent to the movement led by Shivaji against Mughals and Portuguese. It is easy for armchair historians to connect cultural happenings and backdrop to individual’s achievements and convince readers of great wisdom and knowledge about the era to conclude the much accepted cause affect relationship in a social process or mechanism.
Another misconception is that History has to teach lessons for posterity as it tends to repeats itself too often. The latter is true but the argument that History must have a lesson although attractive is too naïve. Actually History does not teach, History Indicates and helps the initiated to conclude a hypothesis. An astute historian if fearless and unbiased , argues based on documents and other evidences with his specialized training to decipher facts and arrive at a most plausible hypothesis which gets accepted by consensus .A professional historian therefore should be flexible and not dogmatic as newer evidences may prop up time to time which may assist him to change or review his theories forcing him on occasion to discard an earlier held premise .A historian is therefore like a clinician who develops a total picture by putting a jigsaw puzzle in place in real life and time.
Is all this important is the key question.Yes It is, for it is the right of every stable society to know as many facts about its roots and ideologies for academic purposes and for cultural reasons. It adds dimensions to the very fabric of a sect or clan and its stream through passage of time for decisions making for the current generations putting relevant issues in perspective. It is imminently necessary not to lose sight of this perspective so that society stands on robust foundations of meritocracy and sustenance.
It is said that in year 1630 there was a terrible mother of famines in central India .Entire villages and towns got wiped out and men turned into beast by forced cannibalism and necrophilia.The details of which have been documented by a Dutch Trader Van Twist .Saint Tukaram another jewel in the crown of Marathi soil has written with great compassion about this devastation in his universal verse .Infact I suspect that Maharashtra turned into a land of saints in medieval india due to war and famines.Dadoji was instrumental in rehabilitating people back which were under his survey a state duty which he performed with finesse as it is claimed
It is at this point we shall digress. In the adjacent article on Archives written by Mukund Kule who talks of need and necessity of preserving state documents in form of archives for historians and scholars who are incidentally and tragically few .Kule again refers to the year 1630 the earliest document available in the Archives .It is in this year that East India company started its operation in Surat by building a huge Fort and Garrison and ware house .The same Surat which was Venice of East where all wealth seemed to get concentrated and which Shivaji plundered on two occasions to fund his military campaigns.
The question now to an ordinary reader of history is: How remotely or closely are these two aspects connected? The great Famine with Setting up shop by the British at Surat in west when they were established in Calcutta.
History tends to dwell on personalities which sways emotions and tends to aggrandize persona .True history is history of setbacks and failures, it is history of destruction and devastation and disasters and famines .It is history of compulsions and deceit, it is a record of alienation and victimization. With the ongoing suicides on epidemic scales in Maharashtra, it is time that we tell our people about this great famine of 1630 and its larger effects on trade and governance and eventual British Supremacy in India .Famines are considered inevitable due to draughts and bad economic policies. Was The famine of 1630 a combination effects of the farmers being taxed by the Marathas, Portuguese,The Adil Shah of Bijapur and the British and of course the extortion by local money lenders. Was Daodoji Kondev equally to be blamed for this turmoil? More and more students of commerce and science and arts ought to join stream of history and decode unanswered questions or else swarms of westerners will descend on the archives which are to be relocated to affluent Bandra Kurla Complex with multinationals and purchased off by rich and powerful to distort history and bend it to suit them including patent law . The University of Mumbai at Kalina Campus would be the right place for the archives to be available for reference work.